Interview Question: What's Your Top Problem-Solving Method?

Yu Payne

August 24, 2023

Updated: October 5, 2025

8 min read

Interview Question: What's Your Top Problem-Solving Method?

As a highly skilled SEO content writer, I am often asked this question in interviews. It is a common question employers ask to gauge the candidates' problem-solving capabilities and analytical thinking. In this article, I will dive deeper into the purpose of this question, the level of interviews it is asked in, the expected answer from the candidate, and provide some possible solutions that can be given. So let's get started!

Why is this question asked?

Employers ask this question to assess candidates' ability to think critically, analyze situations, and develop practical solutions. Problem-solving skills are highly valued in almost every role, as they demonstrate the candidate's ability to handle challenges and contribute to the organization's growth.

This question also helps employers understand a candidate's problem-solving methodology and approach. It gives insights into their creativity, adaptability, and decision-making abilities. By asking this question, employers can evaluate whether the candidate's problem-solving approach aligns with the values and requirements of the company.

Level of interviews it is asked

'What's your top problem-solving method?' is a question that can be asked at various levels of interviews, ranging from entry-level to senior management positions. Employers want to gauge problem-solving skills regardless of the status of the work, as it is a crucial skill for success in any role.

For entry-level positions, employers want to assess the candidate's problem-solving potential and how they handle situations with limited experience. In contrast, for senior-level jobs, employers expect candidates to provide examples of real-life problem-solving scenarios they have faced and the impact of their solutions.

Expected answer from the candidate

When answering this question, showcasing your problem-solving abilities and your capacity to think critically is vital. The expected answer should include a clearly defined problem-solving method you follow, the steps involved in the process, and how you evaluate the success of your solution.

The candidate should also emphasize their ability to gather information, analyze data, evaluate alternatives, and make informed decisions based on available resources. Employers appreciate candidates who can provide examples of how they have tackled complex problems, dealt with obstacles, and achieved successful outcomes.

Possible answers that can be given

The 5-Step Problem-Solving Method

Define the problem: Identify the issue at hand.
Gather information: Collect relevant data and analyze the situation.
Generate alternatives: Brainstorm potential solutions and evaluate each option.
Implement the solution: Select the most appropriate solution and put it into action.
Evaluate the outcome: Assess the results, learn from the experience, and make any necessary adjustments.

The Scientific Method Approach

Observe and define the problem: Carefully observe and define the problem clearly.
Formulate a hypothesis: Develop a tentative solution based on the available information.
Collect data and experiment: Collect relevant data and conduct experiments to test the hypothesis.
Analyze the results: Evaluate the data and draw conclusions based on the findings.
Conclude: Use the results to form a final solution and recommendations.

The Collaborative Approach

Define the problem: Identify the problem statement and gather input from team members.
Brainstorm solutions: Encourage open discussion and generate various potential solutions.
Evaluate alternatives: Assess each solution's pros and cons, considering feasibility, impact, and resources required.
Consensus and implementation: Reach a collective decision and implement the chosen solution.
Monitor and adapt: Monitor the solution's progress, solicit feedback, and adjust if needed.

What to pay attention to when answering?

When answering this question, it is essential to be specific and provide concrete examples of problem-solving situations you have faced. Use the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to structure your response, highlighting the context, the task or challenge, the actions you took, and the positive results achieved.

Demonstrate your ability to collaborate, think critically, and be resilient in challenging situations. Emphasize your adaptability creativity, and how you continually seek to improve your problem-solving skills.

Remember to highlight the importance of data-driven decision-making, as it showcases your ability to gather, analyze, and make well-informed choices.

In conclusion, 'What's your top problem-solving method?' is a question that aims to assess a candidate's problem-solving skills and their approach to tackling challenges. By providing a well-structured answer with concrete examples, highlighting critical thinking, collaboration, and continuous improvement, candidates can impress interviewers and showcase their ability to contribute to the success of an organization.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I improve my problem-solving skills?

To improve your problem-solving skills, start by actively seeking out challenging situations and viewing them as opportunities for growth. Practice critical thinking, research various problem-solving methods, and apply them to real-life scenarios. Additionally, seek feedback from others, learn from your experiences, and constantly aim to expand your knowledge and expertise.

Here is some detailed content on improving problem-solving skills without mentioning any brands:Developing strong problem-solving skills takes time and effort, but it is a worthwhile investment. Here are some tips:- Seek out challenges. Look for opportunities to solve new and difficult problems. Don't shy away from complexity. Tackling tough issues head-on is the best way to build critical thinking and problem-solving muscles.- Learn problem-solving processes. Study methods like root cause analysis, brainstorming, and the five whys technique. Understand the steps involved in diagnosing issues, generating solutions, evaluating options, and implementing fixes.- Observe how experts solve problems. Notice how skilled problem-solvers approach challenges. What thought processes do they use? How do they analyze issues? Emulate their strategies. - Break problems down. Don't get overwhelmed by complexity. Deconstruct issues into smaller elements that are easier to understand and address. Solve things one step at a time.- Research and gather information. Few problems can be solved without data. Take time to thoroughly investigate issues before jumping to conclusions. Get input from diverse sources. - Consider multiple solutions. Don't settle on the first idea. Brainstorm a list of possible fixes and weigh the pros and cons of each. Think creatively. There may be better options than the obvious ones.- Learn from experience. Reflect on both successes and failures. What worked well or didn't work? Update your approach based on lessons learned. Every problem solved develops your skills further.With regular practice and conscious effort, your ability to solve all kinds of problems will improve dramatically. View problems as opportunities, not obstacles.

Should I always aim for a perfect solution when problem-solving?

While seeking a perfect solution is ideal, it is essential to understand that perfection is often elusive. Instead, focus on finding the most practical and effective solution given the available resources and constraints. Aim for continuous improvement, learn from failures, and iterate your answers based on feedback and results.

Here is some detailed content on aiming for perfection in problem-solving:Striving for perfection can be an admirable goal, but it is rarely achievable in real-world problem-solving. Resources like time, money, information, and skills are always limited. Additionally, problems often have multiple valid solutions, rather than a single perfect one. Instead of demanding flawlessness, aim to find the most optimal, practical solution possible within the given constraints. Consider trade-offs, weigh pros and cons, and be willing to make compromises. An 80% solution today is often better than a 100% solution next year. View each solution as an iteration that can be improved over time, not an end point. Learn from failures, adapt based on feedback, and refine approaches. Progress happens in increments, not giant leaps. Stay focused on the actual impact you can make, not abstract ideals.While striving for excellence is admirable, being rigidly attached to perfection can lead to frustration, delay, and analysis paralysis. Be pragmatic and flexible, balancing real-world effectiveness with ideal scenarios. With an iterative mindset and focus on continuous improvement, you can achieve excellence over time.

How can I showcase my problem-solving skills in a job interview?

To showcase your problem-solving skills in a job interview:

Come prepared with examples of challenging situations you have encountered.
Use the STAR method to structure your responses and emphasize your actions, the thought process behind your decisions, and the positive impact of your solutions.
Be concise confident, and demonstrate your ability to think critically and handle complex problems effectively.

Here is a detailed content on how to showcase problem-solving skills in a job interview:When interviewers ask questions about your problem-solving abilities, they want to see how you approach difficult situations and find solutions. Come prepared with examples that demonstrate analytical thinking, creativity, and a methodical approach. One strategy is to use the STAR method - explain the Situation, Task at hand, Action you took, and the Result. For example, In my previous role at IIENSTITU, a client was upset that their order would be delayed. I listened to understand the timeline they needed (Situation). My task was finding a solution that would get them the order on time, despite the production delay (Task). I contacted our manufacturing team to rush the order, and negotiated an expedited shipping option with our logistics partner (Action). This allowed us to meet the client’s deadline as promised (Result).You can also outline the step-by-step process you used to analyze a problem, develop solutions, and implement the best option based on the constraints and resources available. Explain your logic for each decision made. For example, When our team at IIENSTITU noticed a drop in website traffic, I first reviewed analytics to pinpoint the pages with lower visit duration (step 1). Next, I developed two hypotheses for the traffic decline - technical bugs reducing functionality or outdated content (step 2). To test the hypotheses, I ran diagnostics on page speed and conducted A/B tests of new content (step 3). The data showed that outdated content was turning visitors away, so I led a content refresh initiative (step 4). Ask questions to demonstrate your curiosity and strategic approach as well. For example, What metrics do you use to identify problems needing attention? How are solutions evaluated and prioritized here?With compelling examples and thoughtful questions, you can showcase analytical, structured problem-solving skills. Keep your responses clear, detailed and focused on the process rather than just the end result.

Related Courses

Problem Solving Course

Navigating the complexities of today's world requires adept problem-solving skills. Our comprehensive course equips you with proven techniques and methodologies to tackle challenges head-on. Dive in to transform the way you approach and resolve issues, both personally and professionally.

Human Resources Development (HRD)

Unlock the gateway to global recognition in HR with an international certification in human resources development! Embark on a transformative journey that sets you apart, equipping you with globally esteemed skills and credentials.

Workshop Design and Conception

Have you ever wondered how to design a workshop? You can learn how to do with systemic conception and design at IIENSTITU. Also, improve your conflict management and leadership skills.

Interview Question: What's Your Top Problem-Solving Method?

Yu Payne

August 24, 2023

Updated: October 5, 2025

8 min read

Download CSV

Table with 10 rows and 3 columns

5-Step Problem-Solving Method	1. Define the problem 2. Gather information 3. Generate alternatives 4. Implement the solution 5. Evaluate the outcome	Clear decision-making, analysis, evaluation skills, adaptability
Scientific Method Approach	1. Observe and define the problem 2. Formulate a hypothesis 3. Collect data and experiment 4. Analyze the results 5. Conclude	Critical thinking, scientific reasoning, empirical testing, data analysis
Collaborative Approach	1. Define the problem 2. Brainstorm solutions 3. Evaluate alternatives 4. Consensus and implementation 5. Monitor and adapt	Teamwork, open communication, negotiation skills, adaptability
Use of STAR method	1. Situation 2. Task 3. Action 4. Result	Structural thinking, clear communication, evaluation and impact assessment
Data-Driven Decision Making	1. Collect data 2. Analyze data 3. Generate insights 4. Make decisions based on insights	Data analysis, evidence-based decision making, critical reasoning
Adapting to challenges	1. Identify the challenge 2. Analyze potential impacts 3. Develop coping strategies 4. Adapt and adjust as needed	Resilience, adaptability, critical thinking, determination
Creative problem-solving	1. Define the problem 2. Brainstorm creative solutions 3. Test solutions 4. Implement best solution	Creativity, innovation, adaptability, practical application
Root Cause Analysis	1. Identify problem 2. Trace problem to its root cause 3. Develop solutions to fix root cause 4. Implement solution	System thinking, analytical skills, persistent enquiry, effective implementation
Analytical approach	1. Define the problem 2. Break down problem into parts 3. Analyze each part 4. Develop solution	Critical thinking, analytical skills, systematic approach, thoroughness
Risk-Based Problem Solving	1. Identify risks involved 2. Measure risk impact 3. Develop mitigation strategies 4. Implement and monitor	Analytical skills, risk assessment, strategic planning, reactive decision making

Problem Solving Method5-Step Problem-Solving Method

Steps Involved1. Define the problem 2. Gather information 3. Generate alternatives 4. Implement the solution 5. Evaluate the outcome

Key Qualities DemonstratedClear decision-making, analysis, evaluation skills, adaptability

Problem Solving MethodScientific Method Approach

Steps Involved1. Observe and define the problem 2. Formulate a hypothesis 3. Collect data and experiment 4. Analyze the results 5. Conclude

Key Qualities DemonstratedCritical thinking, scientific reasoning, empirical testing, data analysis

Problem Solving MethodCollaborative Approach

Steps Involved1. Define the problem 2. Brainstorm solutions 3. Evaluate alternatives 4. Consensus and implementation 5. Monitor and adapt

Key Qualities DemonstratedTeamwork, open communication, negotiation skills, adaptability

Problem Solving MethodUse of STAR method

Steps Involved1. Situation 2. Task 3. Action 4. Result

Key Qualities DemonstratedStructural thinking, clear communication, evaluation and impact assessment

Problem Solving MethodData-Driven Decision Making

Steps Involved1. Collect data 2. Analyze data 3. Generate insights 4. Make decisions based on insights

Key Qualities DemonstratedData analysis, evidence-based decision making, critical reasoning

Problem Solving MethodAdapting to challenges

Steps Involved1. Identify the challenge 2. Analyze potential impacts 3. Develop coping strategies 4. Adapt and adjust as needed

Key Qualities DemonstratedResilience, adaptability, critical thinking, determination

Problem Solving MethodCreative problem-solving

Steps Involved1. Define the problem 2. Brainstorm creative solutions 3. Test solutions 4. Implement best solution

Key Qualities DemonstratedCreativity, innovation, adaptability, practical application

Problem Solving MethodRoot Cause Analysis

Steps Involved1. Identify problem 2. Trace problem to its root cause 3. Develop solutions to fix root cause 4. Implement solution

Key Qualities DemonstratedSystem thinking, analytical skills, persistent enquiry, effective implementation

Problem Solving MethodAnalytical approach

Steps Involved1. Define the problem 2. Break down problem into parts 3. Analyze each part 4. Develop solution

Key Qualities DemonstratedCritical thinking, analytical skills, systematic approach, thoroughness

Problem Solving MethodRisk-Based Problem Solving

Steps Involved1. Identify risks involved 2. Measure risk impact 3. Develop mitigation strategies 4. Implement and monitor

Key Qualities DemonstratedAnalytical skills, risk assessment, strategic planning, reactive decision making

Interview Question: What's Your Top Problem-Solving Method?

A long-form, native-English interview simulation for a blog audience. It explains a practical, executive-ready problem‑solving system that blends a fast OODA stabilizer with an A3/DMAIC core and MECE structuring—so you can isolate root causes, design experiments, and ship decisions that hold up under audit. The dialogue covers scoping, causal diagrams, baseline math, experiment design, de‑biasing, reversible vs irreversible calls, stakeholder storytelling, and post‑mortem learning that compounds.

🧭

Nora Ellis

SVP, Strategy & Transformation

🛠️

Leo Martinez

Principal Operations Strategist

Hyperion Systems

Important

Nora Ellis

1) What’s your top problem‑solving method—and why that one over all the others?

Leo MartinezAnswer

I run a two‑loop system: a rapid OODA loop to stabilize the situation in hours, and an A3/DMAIC core (Define, Measure/Diagnose, Design, Decide, Deliver) to fix causes and prevent recurrence. OODA gives speed and containment; A3/DMAIC gives depth, evidence, and repeatability. I wrap both with MECE structuring so options are exhaustive and non‑overlapping, and I keep a decision log so our reasoning survives scrutiny.

Nora Ellis

2) Walk me through one end‑to‑end example where you used this method under time pressure.

Leo MartinezAnswer

A checkout conversion dip hit during a promo. OODA: within 90 minutes we confirmed scope, set a safe rollback, and routed paid traffic to the previous stable template. A3/DMAIC: Define a crisp problem statement (mobile CVR −18% vs trailing median), Measure with segmented baselines, Diagnose with a causal DAG that flagged render blocking scripts and copy mismatch, Design two fixes (defer scripts; copy parity), Decide via a paired geo test with guardrails, Deliver behind a feature flag. Result: CVR recovered +21% in 48 hours, then stabilized +8% long‑term.

Nora Ellis

3) How do you scope a problem so you don’t chase noise?

Leo MartinezAnswer

I write a single‑sentence problem statement with who, what, delta, and timeframe. Then a MECE problem tree (process, product, people, policy, platform). I mark non‑negotiables, decision owner, and time horizon. If it doesn’t fit on one page, I’m not ready to assign work.

Nora Ellis

4) Data often lags. How do you move without perfect data?

Leo MartinezAnswer

I estimate a counterfactual from recent baselines, quantify uncertainty with ranges, and act proportionally to reversibility and blast radius. For reversible moves, small experiments beat waiting. For irreversible calls, I expand the information budget—targeted pulls, expert elicitation—and require stronger evidence.

Nora Ellis

5) How do you get from symptoms to causes?

Leo MartinezAnswer

Three tools: Pareto to find the vital few, 5 Whys to probe depth, and a causal diagram (DAG) to separate correlation from mechanism. I validate with disconfirming tests—if the fix doesn’t change the metric via the predicted pathway, it wasn’t the cause.

Nora Ellis

6) What’s your experiment design playbook when stakes are high?

Leo MartinezAnswer

I define the decision the test will change, compute minimum detectable effect and sample/time, pick the design (A/B, geo holdout, diff‑in‑diff), set guardrails for safety metrics, and pre‑register stop conditions. If we can’t act on any outcome, we don’t run the test.

Nora Ellis

7) How do you protect decision quality from bias under pressure?

Leo MartinezAnswer

I run a pre‑mortem, require base‑rate checks, assign a dissent duty to steelman the opposing view, and capture probabilities not certainties. Afterward, a decision review grades the process so good bets that lost aren’t punished and bad bets that won aren’t glorified.

Nora Ellis

8) What if you’re missing key telemetry altogether?

Leo MartinezAnswer

I use structured expert elicitation to form priors, then update with any partial signals via Bayesian reasoning. In parallel, I instrument the missing telemetry as a first‑class deliverable—it’s a root cause if we can’t even observe the system.

Nora Ellis

9) How do you translate analysis into an executive decision quickly?

Leo MartinezAnswer

One page: context, counterfactual baseline, 2–3 options with costs, risks, and expected value, my recommendation, and the decision needed by when. I include reversibility and blast‑radius tags. Leaders move faster when trade‑offs are explicit.

Nora Ellis

10) Speed vs thoroughness—how do you decide when ‘good enough’ is enough?

Leo MartinezAnswer

I classify the decision: reversible/low‑blast (ship with guardrails) vs irreversible/high‑blast (raise the evidence bar). The cost of delay competes with the cost of error. If delay burns more value than likely error, we ship the best reversible plan now.

Nora Ellis

11) Teams and handoffs can derail a great method. What’s your coordination model?

Leo MartinezAnswer

Named DRIs, RACI clarity, and a single source of truth. We keep async status in a living doc, not chat pings. Decisions and assumptions go to a log with timestamps so we don’t re‑debate the past.

Nora Ellis

12) How do you ensure fixes stick instead of bouncing back as new incidents?

Leo MartinezAnswer

Every delivery includes verification (did the metric move?) and institutionalization (SOP change, guardrail, or test added). We schedule a short stabilization sprint to retire debt we consciously took on.

Nora Ellis

13) Biggest anti‑patterns you’ve eliminated?

Leo MartinezAnswer

Jumping to solutions without a problem sentence, gold‑plating analyses no one will use, and treating dashboards as decisions. Also: confusing ‘loud’ data with causal data.

Nora Ellis

14) What metrics prove your method works?

Leo MartinezAnswer

Leading: time‑to‑detect, time‑to‑decision, decision latency. Lagging: incident re‑occurrence rate, rework %, cycle time, contribution margin preserved. Learning: % of decisions with logs and post‑mortems closed.

Important

Nora Ellis

15) How do you teach this method so a team can adopt it in 30/60/90 days?

Leo MartinezAnswer

30 days: problem statements, one‑page briefs, decision logs. 60 days: DAGs and experiment templates, pre‑mortems, guardrails. 90 days: case library, monthly decision reviews, and a standing ‘dissent duty’ rotation.

Important

Nora Ellis

16) Give me your concise, interview‑ready answer to: “What’s your top problem‑solving method?”

Leo MartinezAnswer

“A fast OODA loop to stabilize, then an A3/DMAIC core structured MECE: define the problem crisply, measure a counterfactual, map causes with a causal diagram, design a small reversible test with guardrails, decide with explicit trade‑offs, and deliver with verification and SOP changes. I log decisions, run a pre‑mortem to de‑bias, and track time‑to‑decision and re‑occurrence so the method compounds.”