HomeBlogNavigating the HRM Hierarchy: Challenges & Opportunities
Human Resources Management

Navigating the HRM Hierarchy: Challenges & Opportunities

28 January 2023
A screenshot of a website is shown with a woman in a white turtleneck and black jacket standing on the left side. In the background, a person wearing a hat can be seen. Further in the background, a set of train tracks lead into the ocean. The center of the image displays a computer screen with various elements. On the right side of the screen, there is white text on a black background, with a white letter o in the center. There is also a green text on a black background further down. The image provides a detailed view of a computer screen and the elements surrounding it.

You know, when I first stepped into the world of human resources, I had this naive belief that I'd be directly impacting people every single day. I imagined open doors, seamless communication, and swift decision-making that would benefit both the employees and the organization. However, as I climbed higher up the ladder in the human resource HR hierarchy, I began to realize that things weren't as straightforward as I had hoped. The multitiered HRM hierarchy presented both challenges and opportunities that I hadn't anticipated.

ChallengesOpportunitiesRisks/Dangers
Delays in decision-making and policy implementation due to numerous sign-off requiredStructured approach to decision-makingRisk of returning to HR 'dumping ground'
Lack of understanding and trust due to decision being made by non-HR specialist executiveOpportunities for employees to develop skills and expertise as they climb the hierarchyDecisions made without HRM expert input could lead to ineffective decisions
Lack of communication between different hierarchical levels leading to decision-making breakdownPromotes collaboration and stakeholder involvement in decision-makingLack of expert input could undermine effectiveness of HRM function
Multitiered system can cause hesitance from lower-level HR to express viewsFosters a culture of learning and development within the organizationPotential for decisions without necessary knowledge could lead to HRM function ineffectiveness
Potential lack of trust in decisions made by higher-upsAllows for experience gain in different areas of HRM functionRisk of returning to a 'dumping ground' with decisions lacking necessary expertise
Can lead to delays in change implementation due to numerous sign-offsStructured approach to decision-making ensures organization's best interestsDecisions without HRM expert input could lead to ineffective HRM function
Risk of misunderstanding due to decisions by non-HR executivesOpportunities for employees to improve their skills and knowledgeRisk of decisions being made without necessary expert knowledge
Breakdown in communication between different levels of hierarchyOpportunities for collaboration between different levels of hierarchyIneffective decisions due to lack of HRM expert input
Lower-level HR often hesitate to express their viewsOpportunities to foster learning and development cultureRisk of returning to the dumping ground of HRM
Potential lack of faith in decisions made by executivesOpportunities for employees to gain various experience within HRMRisk of ineffective HRM function due to lack of expert input
  • Introduction

  • Challenges in a Multitiered HRM Hierarchy

  • Opportunities in a Multitiered HRM Hierarchy

  • The Risk of Returning to the "Dumping Ground"

  • Conclusion

When I was just starting out, I remember a colleague telling me, "The higher you climb, the trickier it gets." At the time, I brushed it off, thinking I was prepared for any obstacle. But boy, was I in for a surprise!

Challenges Faced

One of the first challenges I encountered was the delay in decision-making. I recall an instance where we needed to implement a new policy to improve employee engagement. It was a simple enough idea, or so I thought. But the proposal had to pass through what felt like an endless chain of approvals.

1- Multiple Signatures Required: The document had to be signed off by not just my immediate supervisor but also by several managers up the chain.



2- Lack of Understanding: Some of these higher-ups weren't even from HR human; they were executives overseeing various departments. They didn't fully grasp the nuances of the HRM hierarchy or the specific needs of our employees.

3- Communication Gaps: There was a noticeable lack of communication between different levels. Those at the top seldom consulted with those of us on the ground.

I remember feeling quite frustrated. We'd have meetings about meetings, and yet nothing seemed to progress. The red tape was real, and it was underlined by a culture of excessive bureaucracy.

Moreover, there was this unspoken hesitation among my peers. Employees near the lower end of the hierarchy often felt their voices didn't matter. They were reluctant to share their insights or challenge decisions, fearing it might jeopardize their standing. This led to a stifled environment where innovation was scarce.



The "Dumping Ground" Phenomenon

Another significant risk was the potential of HR becoming the proverbial "dumping ground". This happens when:

Non-HR Executives Make HR Decisions: Without proper HR expertise, decisions can be misaligned with the organization's values and employee needs.

Lack of HR Representation: HR professionals aren't adequately represented in strategic meetings, leading to a disconnect between strategic human resource management and actual practice.

I once witnessed a situation where a major decision about employee benefits was made without consulting the HR team. The result? A policy that didn't comply with legal standards and caused an uproar among staff. It took months to rectify the mistake, causing unnecessary strain on human resources resources and trust.

Embracing the Opportunities

But it's not all doom and gloom! Despite these hurdles, there's a silver lining. The multitiered HRM hierarchy can offer numerous opportunities for growth and improvement.

Structured Decision-Making

Firstly, the hierarchy provides a structured approach to decision-making.

Checks and Balances: Multiple levels of approval can prevent hasty decisions that might not be in the best interest of the organization.

Diverse Perspectives: Having various stakeholders involved brings different viewpoints to the table, enriching the final outcome.

For example, when we finally implemented that employee engagement policy I mentioned earlier, the feedback from different departments helped us fine-tune it. The result was a program that was more inclusive and effective than our original proposal.

Professional Development

Secondly, the hierarchy creates avenues for employees to develop their skills and knowledge.

Mentorship Opportunities: Senior staff can mentor juniors, sharing invaluable insights and experiences.

Cross-Functional Collaboration: Working with different levels encourages understanding of various aspects of the business.

I personally benefited from this when I was assigned to a cross-departmental project. Not only did I learn about optimize supply chain management process tips, but I also gained insights into how HR strategies align with broader business goals.

The higher you climb in the HRM hierarchy, the more challenges and opportunities you will encounter.

IIENSTITU
Delays in decision-making and policy implementation due to numerous sign-off required, Structured approach to decision-making, Risk of returning to HR 'dumping ground', Lack of understanding and trust due to decision being made by non-HR specialist executive, Opportunities for employees to develop skills and expertise as they climb the hierarchy, Decisions made without HRM expert input could lead to ineffective decisions, Lack of communication between different hierarchical levels leading to decision-making breakdown, Promotes collaboration and stakeholder involvement in decision-making, Lack of expert input could undermine effectiveness of HRM function, Multitiered system can cause hesitance from lower-level HR to express views, Fosters a culture of learning and development within the organization, Potential for decisions without necessary knowledge could lead to HRM function ineffectiveness, Potential lack of trust in decisions made by higher-ups, Allows for experience gain in different areas of HRM function, Risk of returning to a 'dumping ground' with decisions lacking necessary expertise, Can lead to delays in change implementation due to numerous sign-offs, Structured approach to decision-making ensures organization's best interests, Decisions without HRM expert input could lead to ineffective HRM function, Risk of misunderstanding due to decisions by non-HR executives, Opportunities for employees to improve their skills and knowledge, Risk of decisions being made without necessary expert knowledge, Breakdown in communication between different levels of hierarchy, Opportunities for collaboration between different levels of hierarchy, Ineffective decisions due to lack of HRM expert input, Lower-level HR often hesitate to express their views, Opportunities to foster learning and development culture, Risk of returning to the dumping ground of HRM, Potential lack of faith in decisions made by executives, Opportunities for employees to gain various experience within HRM, Risk of ineffective HRM function due to lack of expert input

Fostering Collaboration

Lastly, a multitiered hierarchy can enhance collaboration.

Interdepartmental Cooperation: Regular interaction with other departments ensures that HR strategies are aligned with the overall company direction.

Unified Goals: Shared objectives promote teamwork and a sense of unity.

By collaborating closely with the supply chain team, for instance, we were able to develop training programs that improved efficiency and productivity. This alignment of human resources and operational goals exemplifies strategic HR management at its best.

Mitigating the Risks

To prevent returning to the "dumping ground" scenario, it's crucial to address the underlying issues.

Enhancing Communication

Open Forums: Encourage open dialogue between all levels of the hierarchy.

Feedback Mechanisms: Implement regular surveys and suggestion boxes where employees can voice their opinions anonymously.

I recall instituting a monthly human resources information session where anyone could ask questions or raise concerns. This simple initiative significantly improved trust and transparency.

Empowering HR Professionals

Autonomy: Give HR professionals the authority to make decisions within their expertise.

Representation: Ensure HR has a seat at the table in strategic meetings.

By advocating for HR's involvement in executive decisions, we ensured that policies were employee-centric and legally compliant.

Continuous Learning

Training Programs: Offer regular training to keep everyone updated on best practices.

Resource Allocation: Provide adequate human resources resources to support HR initiatives.

We invested in professional development courses, which not only improved our team's capabilities but also signaled the organization's commitment to human and resource development.

Reflecting on Personal Experiences

Looking back, I realize that every challenge was a learning opportunity. Navigating the multitiered HRM hierarchy taught me patience, diplomacy, and the importance of effective communication. There were times I felt like I was stuck in a never-ending loop of approvals, but those moments strengthened my resolve to make a positive impact.

I also realized the importance of each facet of HR, from compliance to what we casually called human rec—our shorthand for human recruitment. Every piece plays a part in the larger puzzle of organizational success.

I remember once, after a particularly grueling week, a junior colleague approached me. She said, "Thank you for pushing through with the policy changes. It has really made a difference in how we approach our work." That simple acknowledgment made all the bureaucracy worth it.

Conclusion

In wrapping up, the journey through the human resources hierarchy is akin to a winding road filled with both obstacles and scenic views.

Challenges like delays and communication gaps test our resilience.

Opportunities for structured decision-making and professional growth enrich our careers.

But perhaps most importantly, by recognizing and addressing the risks—like the potential of reverting to a "dumping ground"—we can strive to create a more effective and responsive HR function.

After all, at the heart of human resource HR, it's all about people. By fostering an environment of trust, open communication, and continuous learning, we can ensure that our organizations not only survive but thrive.

So, if you're climbing the HR ladder, remember: each step brings new lessons. Embrace them, and you'll make a lasting difference in your organization.


References

Armstrong, M. (2020). Armstrong's Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice. Kogan Page Publishers.

Ulrich, D., & Brockbank, W. (2005). The HR Value Proposition. Harvard Business Press.

Mathis, R. L., & Jackson, J. H. (2019). Human Resource Management. Cengage Learning.

Schuler, R. S., & Jackson, S. E. (2007). Strategic Human Resource Management. Wiley-Blackwell.


Human Resources HRM Hierarchy Multitiered HRM Hierarchy Challenges Opportunities Risks Decision-making Policies Procedures Executives Employees Communication Trust Structure Learning Development Collaboration Expertise Knowledge Effectiveness
Yu Payne is an American professional who believes in personal growth. After studying The Art & Science of Transformational from Erickson College, she continuously seeks out new trainings to improve herself. She has been producing content for the IIENSTITU Blog since 2021. Her work has been featured on various platforms, including but not limited to: ThriveGlobal, TinyBuddha, and Addicted2Success. Yu aspires to help others reach their full potential and live their best lives.
Yu Payne
Blogger

Yu Payne is an American professional who believes in personal growth. After studying The Art & Science of Transformational from Erickson College, she continuously seeks out new trainings to improve herself. She has been producing content for the IIENSTITU Blog since 2021. Her work has been featured on various platforms, including but not limited to: ThriveGlobal, TinyBuddha, and Addicted2Success. Yu aspires to help others reach their full potential and live their best lives.

Related Posts
Our team of experts is passionate about providing accurate and helpful information, and we're always updating our blog with new articles and videos. So if you're looking for reliable advice and informative content, be sure to check out our blog today.
Discover the role of human resources management in developing and sustaining economic growth.
Human Resources Management

The Role of HRM in a Nation's Growth

01 November 2022
This image shows a group of women standing with their arms crossed. The group consists of four people, one of whom is wearing a black jacket and white shirt with long hair. Another woman is wearing a suit and has her arms folded in front of her. In addition, there is a man in a suit standing in the background. In the foreground of the image, there is a white letter 'O' on a black background and a white letter on a brown surface. Additionally, there is another white letter on a grey background. All the people in the image have neutral expressions on their faces. The background of the image has an orange hue which creates a soft atmosphere.
Human Resources Management

10 Careers in Human Resources Management

04 November 2022
A man in a suit is sitting at a desk in front of a phone. He is wearing a blue shirt with a white collar and a white shirt underneath. He has a serious expression on his face as he talks on the phone. His hands are clasped together and he is holding a phone. In the background, a chair is visible with a close up of a hand holding a tablet. There is also a blurry image of a pen and a book. The man is focused on his conversation and is unaware of his surroundings.
Human Resources Management

What is a Human Resources Information System (HRIS)?

05 December 2022
A group of people sit around a large table, each with a laptop in front of them. One man wears a suit and glasses, looking intently at his laptop. A woman holds her hand up in the air, and a man next to her is waving his hand. In the background, a bright circle can be seen in the sky. In the foreground, a close up of another person's eyes is visible. Additionally, a green letter on a black background is present in the scene. The atmosphere is one of focus and concentration, as the participants work together on their laptops.
Human Resources Management

What's The Easiest Way To Learn Human Resources Management?

17 September 2022
This image is a close-up of a white paper with a red marker on it. The marker is positioned in the center of the paper and is visible in great detail. In the top-left corner, there is a diagram with multiple red circles and a blue arrow. In the bottom-right corner, there is a man in a suit. In the center of the paper, there is a close-up of a word written in red marker. On the top-right corner, there is a close-up of a white board with black text. Lastly, on the bottom-left corner, there is a blue drawing on a blue background. This image has a sense of order and structure, with different elements placed in different parts of the paper. Overall, it is a well-composed image with a lot of detail.
Human Resources Management

7 Essential Human Resources Management Strategies

09 December 2022
A group of people stand in a room, clapping their hands and smiling widely. The man in the center wears a black shirt and glasses, and has a beard. The woman to his left is wearing a dress with a patterned top. The man to the right is in a suit and tie. Behind them, two people are clapping enthusiastically. In the foreground, a close up of a person's legs can be seen. To the side, a board is in focus. Everyone is happy and excited, their faces filled with joy and appreciation.
Human Resources Management

How to Ace the Department of HR Management Interview

16 November 2022
A man is smiling for the camera, wearing a plaid shirt and glasses. His eyes are closed, and a broad smile stretches across his face. He stands in front of a building, with a statue of a woman holding a staff just to the side. In the background a white letter 'O' is visible, appearing twice in the frame to the left of the man. His pose is relaxed, with his arms by his sides and one leg slightly bent. The image is a close-up, capturing the man's face in detail and highlighting his genuine expression of joy.
Human Resources Management

Earn Your Certificate in Human Resources Management Online

16 November 2022
A man in a suit sits at a desk, his right hand resting on his head. He looks deep in thought, a clock ticking on the wall behind him. In the foreground, a close-up of a black tie is visible. To the right, a coffee mug can be seen on the desk, and a white letter ‘O’ on a blue background is visible in the background. The man’s hands are close to a keyboard, and a watch can be seen near the top of the frame. He looks tired and frustrated, his brow furrowed and his eyes firmly closed.
Human Resources Management

5 Types of Employees that Hate Human Resources

13 November 2022